More on the topic. My goal is not to argue a position. It is to explore the arguments. Am I the only person on the planet doing this? Put it this way, I only know people who are locked into a position and none of those people really know very much about the topic.
I don't know much either. It's really complex. You have to be a full blown medical researcher to grasp it. Who has got the time or ability? Unfortunately, we have to trust others.
But who can you trust? Do you trust corporations? Any corporation? If you put complete trust in corporations, you are a fool. I have worked in corporations. Scary.
Do you put complete trust in the government? If you do, you are a fool. I have worked in government. Scary.
But you can trust more in counterbalancing forces, in the private sector keeping an eye on government and government keeping an eye on the private sector, on different parts of government keeping an eye on other parts. Balance of powers. So even if people are selfish, even if they are egotistical, even if they are greedy, the selfishness and egotism and greed can be redirected for the public good. So for example, in a court of law you have two greedy attorneys but because they engage in an adversarial process, they keep a check on one another and hopefully some kind of truth emerges.
Problem is that over the last 30 years, the government and corporate world and the press have morphed into one to a very large extent. I remember when there were more clear divisions in society. Women wore dresses and men pants. Today you can barely differentiate not only by dress but by voice and mentality and choice of partner. There are today many same-sex parents. Who is the mother? who is the father? It's insane.
I remember when TV actors did only television and movie actors only film. Today, there's all kinds of cross over. I remember when you had actors and actresses. Today, they are all actors.
Today it's very common for the heads of agencies like the Securities and Exchange Commission to retire and get lucrative jobs for Goldman Sachs. That's a big problem. It's retroactive bribery. The two worlds need to be separate.
Same thing happens in the pharmaceutical industry. And the result is you can't really trust either side because they have become one.
I remember when there were hundreds of newspapers. Today, most journalism is controlled by a few major corporations.
Still you have to live. You always have attorneys keeping a balance with their goal of becoming rich. But that doesn't work so well in the vaccine business because you cannot sue a corporation for a bad vaccine. You have to go to vaccine court where the bill is paid by the tax payer. That's a big problem and makes this whole business very suspicious.
Anyway, as I said we have to live and do the best we can with the information we have. We daven to Hashem to guide us. There's a risk to taking vaccines and there's a risk to not taking them. So one should examine all sides of the argument and make choices. That's life.
The following
overview discusses some of the most controversial claims about vaccines such as the presence of preservatives, aluminum salts, and formaldehyde and claims they are not problematic. While reading it, I get mixed feelings. One is, well they are providing some kind of answer to critics; although it's easy to oversimplify when talking to the public. The other is, wow this is really complicated. They are playing with fire here. They better know what the heck they are doing. And even if the experts have it all figured out, in the vaccine factories, regular people are working, dummies like us. Are they doing everything right? The American Academy of Pediatrics claims everything is just fine. Do you put complete trust in them? If you do, you are a fool. But if you decide to go with their recommendation, I understand. That's different from complete trust. Here are their words:
Vaccine Ingredients: Frequently Asked Questions
Q. What ingredients are in vaccines?
All vaccines contain antigens. Antigens make vaccines work. They prompt the body to create the immune response needed to protect against infection. Antigens come in several forms. The form used in a vaccine is chosen because studies show it is the best way to protect against a particular infection.
Antigen forms include:
Weakened live viruses. They are too weak to cause disease but can still prompt an immune response. Measles, mumps, rubella, rotavirus, chickenpox, and one type of influenza vaccine contain weakened live viruses.
Inactivated (or killed) viruses. These viruses cannot cause even a mild form of the disease, but the body still recognizes the virus and creates an immune response to protect itself. The polio, hepatitis A, influenza and rabies vaccines contain inactivated viruses.
Partial viruses. These are made up of the specific part of the dead virus that will prompt a protective immune response. Some vaccines are made this way including the hepatitis B and HPV vaccine.
Partial bacteria. are made up of the specific part of the dead bacteria that will prompt a protective immune response. Some vaccines are made this way including the Hib, pneumococcal, meningococcal, diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis (whooping cough) vaccines.
Vaccines also contain other ingredients, which help make them safer and more effective. They include:
Preservatives. They keep the vials from getting contaminated with germs.
Adjuvants. They help the body create a better immune response. These are aluminum salts.
Additives. They help the vaccine stay effective while being stored.
Additives include gelatin, albumin, sucrose, lactose, MSG and glycine.
Residuals of the vaccine production process. Some ingredients are needed to make the vaccine. Although these ingredients are removed, tiny (residual) amounts are left in the final product. Depending on how the vaccine is made, it may include tiny amounts of antibiotics (neomycin), egg protein or yeast protein.
Q. Are these other ingredients in vaccines safe?
A. Yes.
Q. Why are these other ingredients in vaccines?
A. Each ingredient has a specific function in a vaccine. These ingredients have been studied and are safe for humans in the amount used in vaccines. This amount is much less than children encounter in their environment, food and water.
Aluminum salts. Aluminum salts help your body create a better immune response to vaccines. Aluminum salts are necessary to make some of the vaccines we use more effective. Without an adjuvant like aluminum, people could need more doses of shots to be protected. Everyone is exposed to aluminum because there is much aluminum in the earth’s crust. It’s present in our food, air and water, including breast milk and formula. The amount of aluminum in vaccines is similar to that found in 33 ounces of infant formula. Aluminum has been used and studied in vaccines for 75 years and is safe.
Formaldehyde. Formaldehyde is used to detoxify diphtheria and tetanus toxins or to inactivate a virus. The tiny amount which may be left in these vaccines is safe. Vaccines are not the only source of formaldehyde your baby is exposed to. Formaldehyde is also in products like paper towels, mascara and carpeting. Our bodies normally have formaldehyde in the blood stream and at levels higher than in vaccines.
Antibiotics. Antibiotics, such as neomycin, are present in some vaccines to prevent bacterial contamination when the vaccine is made. Trace amounts of antibiotics in vaccines rarely, if ever, cause allergic reactions.
Egg protein. Influenza and yellow fever vaccines are produced in eggs, so egg proteins are present in the final product and can cause allergic reaction. Measles and mumps vaccines are made in chick embryo cells in culture, not in eggs. The much smaller amount of remaining egg proteins found in the MMR (measles, mumps, rubella) vaccine does not usually cause a reaction in egg allergic children.
Gelatin. Some vaccines contain gelatin to protect them against freeze-drying or heat. People with severe allergies to gelatin should avoid getting gelatin-containing vaccines.
Q. Do vaccines contain antifreeze?
A: No. Antifreeze is typically made of ethylene glycol, which is unsafe. Confusion has arisen, because polyethylene glycol (a chemical used in antifreeze and personal care products like skin creams and toothpaste) is used in vaccines and is safe. It is used to inactivate the influenza virus in some influenza vaccines. It is also used to purify other vaccines.
Q. Do vaccines contain mercury?
A: Almost all childhood vaccines do NOT contain any mercury. Methylmercury, which is found in fish and other animals (including humans) can be toxic and lead to adverse effects in humans. Thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative, was removed from most childhood vaccines in 2001. Thimerosal contains a different form of mercury called ethylmercury, which is processed by the body very differently than methylmercury, and is not associated with the same adverse effects. It is still present in some influenza vaccines. Thimerosal is still used in the manufacture of some vaccines to prevent contamination. The thimerosal is removed at the end of the manufacturing process. In some cases, a tiny amount of thimerosal remains. The remaining amount is so small, that it is not possible for it to have any effect. Valid scientific studies have shown there is no link between thimerosal and autism. In fact, autism rates have actually increased since thimerosal was removed from childhood vaccines. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), the American Medical Association (AMA), the CDC, and the Institute of Medicine (IOM) agree that science does not support a link between thimerosal in vaccines and autism. For the IOM report, go to http://www.iom.edu/CMS/3793/4705/4717.aspx.
Q. Do vaccines contain fetal tissue?
A. No. A few vaccines involve growing the viruses in human cell culture. Two cell lines provide the cultures needed for producing vaccines. These lines were developed from two fetuses in the 1960s. The fetuses were aborted for medical reasons, not for the purpose of producing vaccines. These cell lines have an indefinite life span, meaning that no new aborted fetuses are ever used. No fetal tissue is included in the vaccines, either, so children are not injected with any part of an aborted fetus.
Q. Should vaccines be “greener”?
A. The amount of each additive used in vaccines is very small. In fact, we are exposed to much higher levels of these chemicals in our everyday lives. In vaccines, these ingredients are used to make the vaccine safer and more effective. Each vaccine is tested many times to make sure it is safe and works. Taking ingredients out might affect the ability of the vaccine to protect a child. Research is always being done to make sure that ingredients in vaccines continue to be the safest and best available for children.
American Academy of Pediatrics)
Last Updated 2/28/2013
Again, don't let this be the last word on the subject. Put it in your memory banks and keep researching.
